Keycloak vs miniOrange

Keycloak vs miniOrange

High Availability

Provide high scalability and availability.

World Class Support

We provide best technical, architecture, third-party software, launch support and customers vouch for our support.

Flexible IdP

We have such a flexible IdP system where you can enable the SSO for the applications without moving the users from their existing user store.

Support Protocol

SSO into all types of applications which support standard protocols like SAML, OAuth/OpenID, JWT including older protocols like CAS, Radius, WSFED.

miniOrange Unique Features

External Database Integration

Authenticate your users via any external database or API. This is also relevant to your case. Suppose you want to keep your users in WordPress only and do not want to move them. But since WordPress is not an IDP. You can use miniOrange as a broker to authenticate via WordPress database and miniOrange will do session management.

Protocol Brokering

Protocol Brokering helps you to Single Sign-On(SSO) into any application via IDP supporting any protocol SAML, OAuth, OpenId,etc. It allows all your SSO, MFA, User Management requirements with cross protocol support between your apps

SSO Connector Support

miniOrange also provides connectors for many platforms/cms which do not support single sign-on to enable SSO in them like WordPress, Atlassian, Joomla, Drupal, etc.

Limitations of Open Source IdPs

  1. EOL (End-of-Life) -

    One of the major concerns that rely on open-source products is that the host can declare their End Of Life anytime. This is not the case with proprietary solutions.

  2. The difficulty of use -

    Some open source applications may be tricky to set up and use. Others may lack user-friendly interfaces or features or guides that your staff may be familiar with. This can affect productivity and prevent your staff from adopting or using programs with ease.

  3. Compatibility issues -

    Many types of proprietary hardware need specialized drivers to run open-source programs, which are often only available from the equipment manufacturer. This can potentially add to the cost of your project. Even if an open-source driver exists, it may not work with your software as well as the proprietary driver.

  4. Liabilities and warranties -

    With proprietary software, the developer usually provides indemnification and warranty as part of a standard license agreement. This is because they fully control and copyright the product and its underlying code. Open-source software licenses typically contain only limited warranty and no liability or infringement indemnity protection.

  5. Hidden costs -

    Software that is free up-front but later costs money to run can be a major burden, especially if you haven't considered hidden costs from the outset.

Complete Support   | Basic Support | No Support

Feature Details miniOrange Keycloak
Ease of Use & Support
Installation Support Quick & Easy Installation  
Support for Customization Provides customize the solution as per requirements  
Active Support Provide dedicated support for every query with quick response  
End to End Configuration Supports Server & client-side configuration  
Local Language Support Login page, User-facing pages, and Email templates can be customized for different local languages  
No User Migration Needed We have such a flexible IdP system where you can enable the SSO for the applications without moving the users from their existing user store.  
Basic Competency
Availability Provides the solution to both Cloud & On-Premise, Also connectors for many platforms/CMS like WordPress, Drupal, Joomla etc.  
(Support for Both On-Prem and Cloud IdP)
Cost-effectiveness Best cost in the market    
Product functionality Product functionality supports market standards  
Single Sign-On
All Standard Protocols Support Support for all modern protocols like SAML, OAuth, OpenID Connect, JWT including older protocols like CAS, WS-FED, RADIUS for authentication  
Cross-Protocol Brokering Provides support to Connect different platforms which support different protocols  
Third Party IdP Support Integration with third-party Identity Providers  
User Directory Integration Users can authenticate via any user directory like AD/LDAP, any external database like HRMS system, AWS Cognito  
JWT Integration Supports JWT authentication for Login into any mobile app, client-side apps based on js, jquery, react, angular, etc.  
Password Vaulting/Secure Web Authentication Support single sign-on plugins for all popular browsers  
Social Login Integration Number of social login like Facebook, Twitter, Google, etc. used for authentication  
Windows Single Sign-On Integrated Windows authentication  
External Database Integration Can authenticate via any External Database  
API Integration Can authentication via any app APIs  
User/Group Management
User/Group Provisioning Support On-Demand and scheduled sync on daily basis.  
SCIM support Built-in standards-based provisioning (SCIM)  
User Re-Certification Workflow User needs to verify his identity after an interval of time for authorized access  
SAML Integrations
SP & IdP initiated login Provides both Service Provider and Identity Provider-initiated login for Single Sign-On through SAML  
Multiple SP Support Number of service providers supported  
User Provisioning/ Deprovisioning Create, Manage, & Delete information about users on multiple systems    
Multi-Factor Authentication
Support for 15+ authentication methods Number of factors used for authentication  
Popular Authentication methods support Push, QR Code Scan, Soft Token for iOs and Android  
Integrations with the hardware token Integrations with different hardware token types like Display Token, Yubikey  
Backup Methods - Soft Token, OTP Over Email, Security Questions Alternate login methods / Backup Methods for Two Factor Authentication  
2FA integrations with VPN Clients Support Remote authentication by Radius Protocol  
Windows credential provider log in to Windows using credentials of different types viz, password, OTP, etc.  
Third Party MFA Providers Integration with third-party MFA Providers/apps like Google Authenticator, Authy, etc.  
Offline MFA It provides full MFA security on the computer even in Offline mode.  
App protection Provide the ability to add MFA layer to applications  
System Protection Secure Macs & windows systems with MFA at the OS Level  
User self-enrollment & self-management Users can enroll themselves & manage their account  
Adaptive Authentication
Enforce access based on user’s device, location and time Enforce access based on user’s device, location and time  
Limit which devices can access apps — corporate vs. personally owned Limit which devices can access apps — corporate vs. personally owned  
Control which devices can access apps Control which devices can access apps  
Notifications to users and admins via email and SMS In case of any unusual activity, device limit exceeded.  
Security
Login Security & monitoring Restrict & Track user login activity  
Advanced Blocking Block user through various parameters like IP, Country, etc.  
Brute Force & DOS Protection Delay response or limit login attempts in case of attack